Kansas State’s season is hanging by a thread at 2-4, and head coach Chris Klieman’s latest comments about Avery Johnson’s usage have set off a storm among Wildcats fans.
During his Monday press conference, Klieman said he does not want to run Johnson more than 15 times per game. That statement comes despite Kansas State being 7-3 when Johnson has at least 10 carries and undefeated when he reaches 14 carries since 2023.
For a team desperate to salvage its Big 12 season, the decision to scale back Johnson’s rushing role is raising serious questions about the program’s direction heading into Saturday’s clash with TCU.
Avery Johnson Is Kansas State’s Best Chance to Win
Johnson’s dual-threat ability has been the most dynamic part of this offense. When the ball is in his hands, Kansas State has consistently moved the chains and found the end zone.
The Wildcats’ offense has lacked spark without running back Dylan Edwards, who has battled injuries for most of the season. That makes Johnson’s rushing threat even more valuable, yet the staff appears hesitant to lean into it.
Numbers tell the story. Johnson led the team with a 77.1 PFF offensive grade against Baylor, throwing for a career high and adding a rushing touchdown on the opening drive. Taking away that aspect of his game risks neutralizing the one player who forces opposing defenses to adjust on every snap.
Offensive Line Struggles Fuel the Debate
Klieman’s hesitation partly stems from an offensive line that has been inconsistent in designed run situations. The Wildcats’ right side struggled again versus Baylor, where PFF run-blocking grades fell below 50 for several starters.
Still, data shows Kansas State thrives when Johnson is allowed to scramble or run read-option looks. Designed runs have been less effective, but scrambles have kept drives alive and given the Wildcats their most explosive plays.
PFF Grades Reveal Bright Spots and Big Concerns
While Johnson led the offense, center Sam Hecht posted a 78.0 pass-block grade but just 63.6 in the run game, a sign of the ongoing imbalance up front.
On defense, linebacker Kanigal Thomas shined with an 88.8 grade in limited snaps, while veteran defenders like Austin Romaine and Desmond Purnell struggled with missed tackles.
According to PFF, Kansas State missed 16 tackles against Baylor, a stat that cannot carry over into a matchup with TCU’s gritty offense.
TCU Brings a Gritty Challenge to Manhattan
TCU enters Manhattan at 4-1 and 1-1 in Big 12 play, led by quarterback Josh Hoover and transfer running back Kevorian Barnes. Wide receiver Eric McAllister provides a dangerous 6-foot-3 target who thrives on contested catches.
The Horned Frogs’ defense has been sticky in coverage all season, frustrating receivers and forcing turnovers. If K-State’s wideouts — including Jaron Tibbs and Keagan Johnson — are not at full strength, the Wildcats may again need Johnson’s legs to keep drives alive.
The Stakes Could Not Be Higher
A loss to TCU would push Kansas State to 2-5 and virtually erase any shot at Arlington or a bowl game. The Wildcats cannot afford to leave their best weapon sidelined by philosophy.
If Johnson is not featured as a true dual-threat quarterback on Saturday, the Wildcats risk being buried by a TCU team that has momentum and a chip on its shoulder.
Fan Frustration Mounts
Kansas State fans are voicing frustration over what they see as a lack of urgency from the coaching staff. Many point to Johnson’s proven success as both a passer and a runner, demanding that the offense be built around his strengths.
If the Wildcats fail to adjust, speculation about Johnson’s long-term future in Manhattan could heat up — an outcome no one in purple wants to see.
Find More from Blueprint Sports Network
More College Football coverage here.
Subscribe to Locked on Kansas State and never miss a video!
Authenticity is hard to find. Come get your dose of real at Blueprint Sports Network.
